Share

Feedback

Projects

Get an overview about the project outputs and related knowledge

A2) Shared-use of flood defences

Start: 09/2017
End: 09/2021
Status: Active

Contact details

Richard Marijnissen

Wageningen University

Expected outcome

Probabilistic framework to compare and assess the shared-use of flood defences and guidelines for their implementation.

Range of functions that can be encountered on/near a flood defence including housing on a riverine dike (top photo), vegetated foreshores in coastal areas with adapted design for the extraction of deposited clay (bottom-left) and more (unusual) objects that can be found (bottom-right). (Photos accordingly available from molendatabase.nl, Regional Water Authority Hunze en Aa's and Richard Marijnissen).

Motivation and practical challenge

My contribution both as engineer and researcher is to understand the middle ground between man and nature. Flood defences protect us from the water but are also integrated with many other functions such as housing and nature. Depending on the location, some functions are more common than other ones (see photo). This shared-use of the flood defences often comes with conservative estimates for a robust design that guarantees the flood safety. While having multi-functional flood defences generally impose restrictions on the design, some elements in the natural foreshores or flooded areas near the dike can contribute to reducing flood risk. For example, vegetated foreshores in coastal areas can damp the amount of wave energy that reaches the dikes. Aside from natural values, coastal salt marshes can also capture clay over time which may be used in future dike reinforcements. With the new probabilistic risk approach recently adopted in the Netherlands, we may be able to quantify the effects on flood safety of both standard and nature-based reinforcement measures. Yet, an integrated risk assessment framework is required.

Research challenge

The objective of this research project is to gain more insight into the shared-use of flood defences on flood risk reduction. I do so by using the new probabilistic risk approach to determine the safety level of flood defences that are shared with traditional functions such as housing. I further assess the effects on flood safety of some nature-based measures applied in innovative dike reinforcements.

Research components to devise a framework for integrating additional functions within the new risk standards.

Innovative components

My research integrates already existing work in flood protection, risk management and nature-based engineering into a risk assessment framework. To develop this framework, I used existing assessment procedures to estimate the probabilities of dike failure for typical mechanisms (top-left figure). Under presence or absence scenarios of housing and trees, I compared the effects of multiple reinforcement measures such as broadening or heightening the dike for a more robust design (top-centre figure). I further extended the framework to assess the effects of dike reinforcements that include salt marsh development as nature-based adaptation measure for sea-level rise (top-right figure).

I am applying the concepts of this framework into two innovative case studies (bottom figures): the Wide Green Dike, and the Double Dike. How are the dike designs adapted for additional functions such as clay mining and salt marsh development? Moreover, what are the synergies and risks that these functions provide to dike safety? In the final step, insights from developing the extended framework, as well as the application cases are synthesised. Thereby, I can provide some recommendations for assessing the effects of other (nature-based) functions within the new flood risk standards.

Relevant for whom and where?

The results are beneficial for users involved in designing, maintaining, assessing and drafting policies for flood defences within the new risk-based approach. All-Risk is supported by the Regional Water Authorities in the north of the Netherlands who are keen to integrate the results into current and future dike reinforcement projects.


The research components are applied into two innovative projects for dike reinforcement located in the north of the Netherlands.

Progress and practical application

Conservative estimates of failure probabilities for flood defences with multiple functions lead to a systematic underestimation of the reliability of these dikes. Instead, the extended approach incorporates the probability of different scenarios in which elements such as houses and trees affect the flood defence to evaluate its safety. In some situations, the probability of a dike failure may turn out to be 100 times stronger than would conservatively be estimated. Not only for traditional functions but also nature-based functions, the framework can be more adaptable. Natural foreshores can expand over time and partially mitigate the effects of future sea-level rise on the flood defence. Moreover, the deposited sediments may provide a source of material for future reinforcements. Recognising the potential of multiple functions is vital to strengthen the Dutch flood defences for the future efficiently. For a detailed description of the findings, click on the related outputs below

Status for day-to-day practice

Numerous combinations of functions can be integrated into a flood defence system with shared-uses. The goal of this project is to provide an extended framework for recognising the risks and synergies of different uses with flood protection.

Next steps

In the next steps, we will continue to research promising multi-functional dike concepts beyond housing and nature conservation.

Last modified: 19/10/2020

Contributing researchers

Richard Marijnissen

Wageningen University

Supervisory team

dr. ir. Jantsje M. van Loon Steensma

Wageningen University

prof.dr. Carolien Kroeze

Wageningen University

prof.dr.ir. Matthijs Kok

Delft University of Technology

Contributing partners

A wide green perspective on dikes

Modelling the salt marsh and borrow pit helping a hand against the sea-level rise

Richard Marijnissen

Wageningen University

View storyline

View storyline

Project outputs

A sustainable adaptation scheme for a wide green dike

Feasibility of extracting salt marsh sediment for dike reinforcement as a climate adaptation strategy in several sea-level rise scenarios.

02/06/2020 by Richard Marijnissen et al.

View publication

Bevat: Publication open access journal

The sensitivity of a dike-marsh system to sea-level rise

Model-based exploration of the future need for dike heightening due to: (1) sea-level rise, (2) changes in sediment concentration, (3) a retreat, and (4) compaction of the salt marsh.

10/01/2020 by Richard Marijnissen et al.

View publication

Bevat: Publication open access journal

Re-evaluating safety risks of multifunctional dikes with a probabilistic risk framework

An additional step to the basic assessment allows estimating the probability of the presence and absence scenario of nature and housing for the reinforcement of a typical Dutch river dike for flood safety.

10/04/2019

View publication

Bevat: Publication open access journal

Blogs

Bringing All-risk to practice: Martin’s recommendations

08/10/2020 by Wim Kanning

This blog is based on an informal interview between Martin Schepers (manager flood safety projects) and Wim Kanning (All-Risk researcher) on the development of...

View blog

All blogs

Events

06/10/2021

PhD Defence - Shared-use of Flood Defences

October 6, 2021 at 16:00, including an (online) mini-symposium before the defence between 12:00 and 14:30 - Please register to receive updates on the event and, in case it is possible, join the symposium.

View event

All events

Videos

The Wide green dike a pilot reinforcement project on the Wadden Sea area

21/04/2020

View video

All videos